Pie Menu
~ sweet & savory ~
About our menu: (UPDATE IN PROCESS)
Signature Pies: These are our signature items. We do our best to keep them in stock or on rotation. Some are special order and/or seasonal.
Specialty & Seasonal: These pies make it to the case when seasonal ingredients are available, we get special orders, or during certain holidays. Most of the pies can be special ordered as long as the ingredients are in season.
Retro Classic Pies: These are the pies grandma and grandpa used to talk about? Or if you were lucky, even make for you. These pies are rotated in to the mix with all the others. The best way to guarantee that we have one is to special order one.
We would love to keep something for everyone in the case at all times, but we just don't have a case big enough. That means that just because you see it below, doesn't mean you will see it in the case at the shop. Just call ahead and follow us on social media.
Most of our items can be made special order for you with a 48-72 hour notice (more is even better if you are the plan ahead type). So, If you don’t see what you are looking for, just contact us, we will do our best to make it for you.
Have something special you want? We make custom orders too, if we have the ability and resources to do so. A custom order fee applies.
Anytime Idaho Pie $24.99
a vanilla cakey-cookie batter baked with...
blueberries & toasted almond, or
marionberry & toasted pecans
Apple-Salted Caramel $29.99
sliced green apples lightly sweetened and baked with our caramel sauce, lattice top
Apple Praline $29.99
sliced green apples lightly sweetened, brown sugar pecan crumble top
Banana Cream $34.99
banana custard & sliced bananas inside
a full graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream & vanilla wafer crumbles
Banana Pudding $35.99
banana custard, vanilla wafers, & sliced bananas inside a full vanilla wafer crust, topped with whipped cream &vanilla wafer crumbles
Blueberry Crumble $29.99
blueberries topped with our sugar butter crumble
Boise Berry $34.99
our mixed berry pie with huckleberries, marionberries, & raspberries topped with a lattice crust
Cherry $29.99
traditional tart pie cherries topped with our traditional crust
Chocolate Cream $34.99
creamy chocolate pudding inside a full chocolate cookie crust topped with whipped cream & chocolate shavings
Chocolate Éclair Pie $34.99
light pastry crust filled with vanilla cream,
topped with a dark chocolate ganache
Chocolate Velvet $34.99
dark chocolate mousse made with imported French chocolate inside a chocolate cookie crust topped with whipped cream & chocolate shavings
Chuckleberry $35.99
Idaho huckleberries & tart cherries, lattice top
Coconut Cream $34.99
coconut custard with coconut flakes inside a full graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream & toasted coconut
Florida Key Lime $29.99
authentic Florida key lime filling inside our graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream dollops
Ginger Lemon Cream $34.99
light lemon cream with ginger inside a full graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream dollops
Huckleberry $44.99
Idaho huckleberries topped with our traditional crust
Huckleberry Cream $35.99
Idaho huckleberry compote & vanilla cream topped with crystalized sugar top in our traditional crust
Lemon Cream $34.99
light refreshing lemon cream inside a full graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream dollops
Peach, Georgia $29.99
sweet peaches cooked in cream inside our traditional crust
Peach - Salted Caramel $29.99
sliced peaches lightly sweetened with our salted caramel
topped with a lattice crust
Peanut Butter Cream $34.99
creamy peanut butter filling inside a chocolate crust topped with chocolate ganache & chopped Reese's cups
Pecan $29.99
toasted pecans with a rich caramel like filling baked inside our traditional crust
(add $5 for Bourbon pecan)
Pecan, Chocolate $29.99
our pecan pie with chocolate chips baked & a chocolate ganache drizzle
(add $10 for Bailey's or Kahlua pecan)
Triple Berry $29.99
blackberries, blueberries, & strawberries in our traditional crust
NOTE: many of our cream pies are available in a half size 7" deep round
Signature Pies
Retro-Classic Pies
Apple $24.99
traditional double crust pie with lightly sweetened green apples
Banana Cream or Meringue $29.99
banana custard & sliced bananas inside our traditional crust topped with whipped cream or meringue.
Buttermilk Custard $24.99
vanilla or chocolate buttermilk custard baked in our traditional crust
Chocolate Cream or Meringue $29.99
chocolate pudding inside our traditional crust topped with whipped cream or meringue
Coconut Cream or Meringue $29.99
coconut custard with coconut flakes inside our traditional crust topped with whipped cream or meringue
Custard Pie $24.99
vanilla egg custard baked inside our traditional crust
French Silk $29.99
creamy chocolate filling inside our traditional crust topped with whipped cream
Lemon Meringue $29.99
tart lemon curd in our traditional crust topped with meringue
We proudly serve CloverLeaf Ice Cream
Apple Caramel Crisp $29.99
sliced green apples lightly sweetened and baked with our caramel sauce, brown sugar oat crisp top
Apple Cream $29.99
sliced green apples baked in sweet cream, brown sugar streusel top
Apple Crumble $29.99
sliced green apples lightly sweetened with our butter sugar top
Black & Blue $29.99
marionberries & blueberries baked in our double crust
Cannoli Pie $34.99
creamy ricotta, mascarpone filling with chocolate chips inside a vanilla wafer & toasted pistachio crust
Cascade Wild Berry $34.99
wild Cascade berry mix inside our traditional crust with our brown sugar oat crisp top
Cherries Jubilee $34.99
Black cherries cooked with bourbon in our traditional crust & lattice top
Chocolate Toffee $39.99
dark chocolate ganache and a soft toffee pecan layered on a chocolate cookie crust topped with whipped cream dollops
Crunch Berry $29.99
marionberries & raspberries topped with our brown sugar pecan crumble
German Chocolate $29.99
rich chocolate filling in side our traditional crust covered with a sweet coconut caramel pecan top
Marionberry $29.99
marrionberries topped in our traditional crust
Huckleberry Peach $35.99
Idaho huckleberries & sliced peaches topped with a lattice crust
Kentucky Derby $29.99
walnuts* and chocolate chips inside our traditional crust topped with a cookie like pastry crust (*pecans on request)
(add $5 for the REAL pie w/bourbon)
Strawberry Rhubarb $24.99
strawberries & rhubarb baked in our traditional crust with a lattice top
Sugar Cream $24.99
vanilla cream filling topped with crystalized cinnamon sugar in our traditional crust
Apricot Pie $24.99, Black Cherry $29.99, Blueberry $29.99, Caramel Chess $24.99
Chocolate Chess $24.99, Chocolate Crack $24.99, Chocolate Mousse $29.99
Peach $29.99, Pineapple $24.99, Raspberry $29.99
Specialty & Seasonal Pies
Chicken Pot Pie
diced chicken in our creamy roux with mixed veggies in our traditional crust
Dublin Pie
ground beef & lamb, mushrooms, onions, cooked in a locally brewed dark ale gravy, topped with cheese and crust
42 oz egg quiche
green chile & three cheese | bacon, jalapeno & three cheese | bacon, mushroom & swiss | ham & cheddar | spinach & roasted tomato |
other random daily & seasonal flavors
beef | Dublin | jalapeno popper |
other random daily & seasonal flavors
Savory Pies
Lg 42 oz $29.99 | SM 22 $19.99
Quiche
$29.99
Shepherd’s Pie
our ground beef version in gravy with mixed veggies topped with mashed potatoes & melted cheese
Vegetable Pot Pie
mushrooms and mixed veggies cooked in our seasoned roux in our traditional crust
special order only
Cajun Chicken Pot Pie
diced chicken in our creamy Cajun roux with mixed veggies in our traditional crust
special order only
Savory Hand Pies
$5.49 - 2 for $9.99
Special Dietary Pies
These are some our "go-to" special diet pies. We can make plenty more and much of what you see in our regular menu above can be adapted. As demand & popularity grows we will do our best to rotate one of these in the case.
Most of our special diet items are special order only and require 48+ hours notice.
The 7" pies are also available in our full 9" size.
Gluten Free
7" Cheesecake $24.99
traditional filling in a crumb crust topped with a sweet sour cream top
7" Chocolate Mousse $19.99
dark chocolate mousse inside a chocolate almond crust topped with whipped cream & chocolate shavings
7" French Chocolate Torte $19.99
flour-less French chocolate torte topped with ganache, powdered sugar, or toasted marshmallow frosting
7" Lemon Cream $19.99
lemon chiffon filling inside a crumb crust topped with whipped cream dollops
Mixed Berry Crumble Pie $24.99
mixed berries baked with our sugar crumble top (9" standard deep)
Keto
7" Cheesecake $26.50
traditional filling in a almond-coconut crust topped with a sour cream top
7" Chocolate Mousse $22.50
dark chocolate mousse inside a chocolate almond crust topped with whipped cream & chocolate shavings
7" Coconut Cream $22.50
coconut custard in an almond-coconut crust topped with whipped cream
Mixed Berry Crumble $29.99
mixed berries baked with our keto crumble top (9" extra deep)
Vegan
7" Chocolate Mousse $19.99
dark chocolate mousse inside a chocolate almond crust topped with whipped cream & chocolate shavings
7" Coconut Key Lime Chiffon $24.99
key lime coconut cream chiffon filling inside a graham cracker crust
7" Peanut Butter $19.99
sweet creamy peanut butter filling inside a chocolate crust topped with a peanut butter drizzle & chopped peanuts
Peach Praline Pie $29.99
sliced peaches baked with our pecan crumble top