Nextdoor
Voted Best Dessert Shop in Boise, 2026
Three years running as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Fave, voted by Boise neighbors — and in 2026, Best Dessert Shop in the city.
Features & press
In the news.
Kind words from Boise writers, and the features we’re proud of. Writing about us? We’d love to hear from you through our contact form.
One of 64 pie shops competing for America’s Best Pie
Boise Pie Co. has been selected for The64’s America’s Best Pie tournament — a 64-shop bracket running from November 5 through the championship on November 23. Our first-round matchup is against Michele’s Pies, and it opens on November 5.
Vote for us →
BusinessRate
Top 3 Pie Shop, Northern Rockies Region
BusinessRate named Boise Pie Co. a Top 3 Pie Shop in the Northern Rockies Region for 2026, based on Google review ratings.
A new chapter on the Bench
A neighborhood feature on Boise Pie Co. and what’s next under Emily’s ownership is on its way to print. We’ll share it here the moment it’s out.
Coming soonNamed Idaho’s best apple pie
Even the gluten-free apple pies garner high praise.
Mashed’s state-by-state roundup picked Boise Pie Co. for Idaho, calling out the tart Granny Smith filling, the salted caramel apple sold beside it daily, and a gluten-free version readers call the best they’ve had.
Read the piece →Sam Eats Local: Boise Pie Co. — cute and cozy
I was blown away.
Boise Weekly’s dining column dropped in for the Rising Sun breakfast sandwich and stayed for the pie — calling out the Florida Key Lime and the peanut butter pie, the welcoming staff, and the rustic, cozy room.
Read the piece →Filling Boise’s takeaway-pie gap
As longtime pie stops disappeared from the valley, BoiseDev looked at the family-owned shop keeping whole holiday pies on Boise tables — from Salted Caramel Apple to Chicken Pot Pie — right from the Bench.
Read the piece →Named among the best pies in Boise
Excellent lunch and excellent pie!
When WOW Country went hunting for where the best pies in Boise are hiding for National Pie Day, Boise Pie Co. led the list.
Read the piece →Plus the ones our neighbors write every day — Yelp ranks us among the best pie in Boise, and Google has us at 4.6 stars across 250+ reviews.